Virtual reality is still fake

Over the weekend I spent a morning hiking in the mountains, enjoying the last of the fall colors. I live in Utah, which will never be a serious contender with New England for “Best Places to View Fall Foliage” but we do have our moments. I nevertheless had to shake my head to see this article on Popular Mechanics’ website today: A Drone’s Eye View Is By Far the Best Way to See the Leaves Changing. Yes, the video is pretty, but given the choice of watching the video and actually being there…no contest.

I’m not dissing pictures or video, mind you. They have their place. I learn a lot about places I can’t go via imagery. But that’s a pale substitute for being there, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise, no matter what Popular Mechanics may say. No video will ever be able to capture the feel of moist earth and musty leaves underfoot as you walk from sun into shade and feel the air grow suddenly cooler on your skin, the scent of soil and pine and decaying matter and mountain breezes in your nostrils, the whispered rush of air through the leaves mingled with the crystal calls of birds and small creatures rustling in the undergrowth, or the sudden blaze of color as you round a turn and see, through the silver-white trunks of birches, a splash of blazing yellow amongst the stolid green of evergreens on a hillside across the dizzying ravine below.

That cannot be even approached, let alone surpassed, by a video, no matter how high the definition. My daughter perhaps put it best, “My eyes hurt from trying to see everything at once!” When we live our lives through a screen that takes up at best a quarter of our vision it’s easy to forget that the real world is more vivid than can ever be captured by any medium. Anything short of the real thing is a reproduction, and reproductions fall short.

I can forgive Popular Mechanics for their gross exaggeration. They are running an online information site, and therefore have to continually find new ways to entice increasingly-jaded eyeballs, which lately means bold-faced lying in headlines. They just won’t get the views if they tell the truth: “This drone footage shows some really nice views of fall leaves.” The trouble is there are generations of people who are growing up to believe their exaggerations: Why actually go out and experience the world when I can see drone footage on my smartphone screen?

My daughter’s reaction was interesting and sad and reassuring all in one. At least I’m doing my duty as a human being in reminding my children that, while there is certainly beauty to be found in manmade creations or reproductions, actual experiences can be more beautiful still–and in fact provide mental fodder to add meaning to man’s attempts to capture that beauty. It’s easier to appreciate the beauty and excellence of a work of art when you know how close they came to capturing the reality in spite of the limitations of the medium. As beautiful as the scenery was in “The Lord of the Rings”, I’d rather see it in person. But my own experiences with similar scenery provided me with sensory memories for those images to tie into in evoking that awe.

Perhaps I would have appreciated the cityscapes of Coruscant in the Star Wars prequels had I spent time in New York City or Los Angeles or Tokyo or Rio De Janeiro. But even my experiences with the downtown areas of Salt Lake City and Brisbane, Australia give me some emotional foundation from which Lucas could build.

As I said, I’m not saying there is no value to imagery over reality. Imagery can take us far in learning about and appreciating places or things or events we will likely never see in person. I do collect images that fire my imagination; Mount Roraima wreathed in clouds, Lake Bled in Slovenia, the salt flats of Bolivia after a rain, for examples. But I don’t for a moment believe I’m getting the full experience I could have in actually being there. Drone footage of New England leaves is pretty, but it’s no substitute for being there.

I recently read a biography that described the meetings of the Inklings, a group of literary-minded intellectuals headed up by C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. I only was able to appreciate the descriptions because I’ve been involved in real group gatherings of that very sort and know how energizing, inspiring, and synergistic such conversations can be. I regularly play a table-top RPG with good friends of mine via Skype, and even when we have a video feed along with the audio it still fails to capture the experience of actually being there.

Don’t let click-bait superlative fool you. There is no substitute for actual experiences. A drone video capture is no better a way to enjoy fall foliage than licking the package of cookies is better than eating the actual contents. Anyone who says differently is selling something.

Posted in Moments of Beauty, Random Musings | 8 Comments

Dog Lake

100_5672The kids had a couple days off from school this week, so I took today off work. We all headed up Millcreek Canyon to the Big Water Trail up to Dog Lake. We figured we’ve got the dog, they’ve got the lake–it’s a perfect combination!

We’ve missed the peak of the fall foliage, but the mountain is still quite resplendent. It was a beautiful day out, though a little chilly to begin with. We didn’t notice after a while, partly because Sam likes to climb mountains even faster than Richard!

100_5681Dog lake is about three miles up, along the ridge between Millcreek and Big Cottonwood Canyons. There are actually two ways to get there, but only one trail allows dogs. It took us a awhile, but we finally found it.

Sam is a black lab, so we were a bit surprised that he’s not really a water dog. He doesn’t mind getting wet, but it’s not his favorite thing by any stretch. He was happy enough to chase sticks into the lake, but if we threw them too far out he would just let them go. One time he went too far out and had to swim a little to get back, and that was it for him.100_5684
He wasn’t about to chase anything more than about five feet from shore. The important thing is that he didn’t want to stop playing, in any case. We’d still be up there now if he had his way. But we were big meanies and made him come back down with us. 100_5697We thought he would be a little tired after that, but no. He pulled us all the way down the mountain, too. And when we got home he was still ready to play.100_5705

Of course now that we’re home and had lunch and everyone gone their own direction he’s finally crashing. That’s our Sam: play hard, sleep hard, live life with gusto.

Millcreek Canyon has some really nice trails. You have to pay a little per car to get in, but it was well worth it for the gorgeous scenery, fresh mountain air, and the last hurrah of fall colors. It’s really a treat to have trails this nice so close to home.

Posted in Random Musings | 6 Comments

Time travel

I don’t think YouTube knows what to do with me. Every time I go there they present me with a page full of recommendations based on what they think I like. If I click on one of those links and watch a video they seem to think I like everything like that and start showing me a bunch of stuff from that same channel. Far too often, one is enough, and I don’t want to see more like it, so I click to tell them I’m not interested. They’re probably thinking, “Make up your mind!!”

Everybody wants to rule the world. Unless there’s time travel, and then they want to kill Hitler.

Posted in Random Musings | 1 Comment

Thank you for the start

Four years ago The Piano Guys were still trying to get off the ground. They were selling pianos by day and making videos by night–and not getting where they wanted to be with either. The took a chance on their fans and found their fans were willing to give them what they needed to make the jump to focusing on the music and videos. The rest is history. The Piano Guys, by all apparent measures, is a successful business venture, delivering quality product that delights their customers and inspires loyalty.

Now here we are. Over fifty videos with 700 million views, four million YouTube subscribers, a million Facebook fans, and four albums with Sony. We’ve sold out shows in the U.S., Mexico, China, Germany, Canada, Singapore, Hungary, Austria, England, Scotland, France, Korea, Turkey, Russia, Brazil, and Japan. And best of all, our families haven’t starved! All because of our Founders. Had it not been for your support and faith in us, we would not be The Piano Guys today.

They decided to say thank you to those initial investors with this video:

Five years ago someone else gave my partners and I our start. Bill and I were both struggling to find suitable work. Reed was still employed, but at a place growing increasingly difficult to enjoy. That’s when Spencer entered the picture, willing to take a chance on the three of us and front the cash to start VIP Gamestore.

Four out of five businesses don’t make it five years. We’re proud (and to no small amount relieved) to be in that 20% of success stories. It was a nail-biter early on. We nearly ran out of Spencer’s money before we started making more than we were spending. It would be a year and a half before our patient investor began seeing a return on his investment. I hope by now he’s pleased with his long-term ROI.

Things have changed over that period, of course. I had to bow out of active involvement in order to take work in another state, but I still keep a hand in as much as I can from three hundred miles away. We were finally able to replace the DVD portion of our store which we really only had so that we wouldn’t look more pathetically understocked than we already did when we opened. Reed’s had a few more kids. Bill’s had a few leave the nest. We’ve probably all had some hair turn gray (or fall out–or both).

But VIP Gamestore continues to grow. And for that we have Spencer (and Lydia) to thank. There’s no saying (and we’d prefer not to try to imagine) where we’d be today without that show of faith (and buckets o’ cash).

I was talking to a local store owner the other night and he mentioned how difficult it can be sometimes to work with his primary investor. While I could understand his problem, and felt for him, it wasn’t from experience. Spencer has been amazingly calm and hands-off the entire time. We were biting our nails at times, but if he was at all nervous about where things were going he never let on.

VIP has been my only real business venture, but I’m not blind. I can see from observation that we’ve been fortunate to gather this particular group of partners. I’ve never had to feel uncomfortable about our business practices or philosophy. We do our best to do right by everyone–even our competitors–and at no time has any of us suggested we do otherwise. I like shopping at places like that, and I’m proud that I’m a partner in a place like that.

Five years (give or take a few days). We dreamed of making it that long, but the realization of that dream was by no means certain. Those first few months were exciting and frightening, frustrating and amazing. It was some of the most fun I’ve had in my working life. And regardless of where things go, VIP Gamestore will always be one of my proudest accomplishments.

I hope Spencer feels the same way. At the very least I hope he doesn’t view his contribution as “just money.” There’s no denying the money was critical. We couldn’t have started at all without it. But along with that money was a tremendous show of faith. He believed in us, in our plan and in our ability to carry it off. I don’t know if he realizes what that can mean to a couple of guys going through a rough patch in life.

His contribution was much more than money, and I hope he feels recompensed in much more than money. What he did has made a huge difference in the lives of three other families (and, in turn, in the lives of our customers, we’d like to think).

Thank you, Spencer. And thank you Bill and Reed for five amazing years. Here’s to many, many more!

 

On a side note, this is an interesting video about “What it’s like to run a video game store”. Though the examples are somewhat one-sided, and we may differ in opinions about the future outlook, this is a fairly accurate depiction of what it’s like:

Posted in Business, Gratitude, Random Musings | 1 Comment

Aspirations: Stone skipping

I love skipping rocks, but this guy, Kurt Steiner, takes it to a whole new level. He’s the current world record holder, with 88 skips.

But clearly even the experts don’t get it right all the time. And, not surprisingly, people can turn this into a competition with rules and regulations.

Here’s one of the comtestants from the second video explaining how he got into it.

Okay, I don’t think I’ll become a competitor, but I’d like to improve my rock-skipping. I guess I need to watch these guys more carefully and see what I can learn.

Posted in Random Musings | Comments Off on Aspirations: Stone skipping

Be still my soul

Just because…

Perhaps my most favorite hymn of all time, made only more poignant by my having married a Finn, and having visited the beautiful country that inspired the tune. This is a gorgeous arrangement.

Posted in Moments of Beauty, Random Musings | 1 Comment

Wisdom vs. Ageism

Gandalf was old. Dumbledore was old. Obi Wan Kenobi was old. Curly in City Slickers was old. It seems in our literature and entertainment, at least, we equate wisdom with age. Even in our Sunday comics the guru at the top of the mountain, to which everyone goes for wisdom, is an old guy.

Funny, then, that in everyday life we immediately assume that any old person is out-of-touch at best, knee-deep in dotage at worst. Except for the Dalai Lama, so long as he keeps his jokes politically correct, of course, or Pope Francis on a good day.

I suspect the wisdom of our elders is relative–relative to whether or not we like what they have to say. Indulgent grandparents are great when we’re the kids they’re indulging, but transform into obnoxious saboteurs when it’s our kids they’re hopping up on sugar and handing back to us.

But in that light, I have to wonder where we got the wise elder stereotype in the first place, then. Did it used to be true, and we’re just producing an inferior crop of elderly these days? Or are we just experiencing another form of that proverbial teenage malady of “the older I get, the smarter my parents become”?

I’d vote the latter. We see them struggle with new tech, for example, and assume that, just because they’re struggling with a smartphone, they’ve never experienced disruptive tech before and have no frame of reference that could apply. It’s more likely a different, related form of teenage malady, the “no one could ever understand me and what I’m going through.” We find it easy to believe that the elderly couldn’t possibly understand conditions today, and couldn’t possibly be clued in enough to have any applicable wisdom to share.

Especially if it’s a message we don’t want to hear.

And I suppose, for some people, or for some topics, that’s probably true. I wouldn’t go to my mom, for example, for advice on how to fix my computer. But I’ll bet she knows more than I might suspect about how to encourage my kids to maintain balance in their time on the computer or smart phones and other activities. It may not have been smart phones, but I suspect that the television and video game systems were a similar concern when she was raising me, and whatever insights she gained from hard experience would probably apply.

But no, we like to think we’re special, that today’s troubles have no analog (pun intended) in the “old days”, and that we’re breaking new ground in our wisdom of youth. The elderly are far too chill about all of this–or far too worried–and can’t be trusted to know the real score. They can’t possibly understand the complex times we live in. Right?

I hear that–or variations thereon–said about the leaders of my church, for example. People feel that having so many old people running the show can’t be a good thing. They’re out of touch. They can’t possibly understand the new, modern world  we live in. They’re too mired in the ideas and morality of the past. At best they really need us young people to help them sort things out.

It’s actually rather amusing, when you think about it. Laying aside whether or not they have direct access to divine wisdom, these aging gentlemen spend much of their time each year traveling around the country and around the world. They probably talk to more people in the space of a month than I do in a year, and more new people in a week. Among the fifteen top leaders of the church, they probably visit more foreign countries in a month than I’ve even flown over in my life. They probably have more “on the ground” experience with foreign nations and the issues facing their people than most US Presidents have after their term of office, let alone before.

But they’re so old!! Why, some of them only got on Facebook this year! Most of them still haven’t!

Considering my love-hate relationship with Facebook, I’m not sure that’s not a point in their favor, actually.

I think it’s terribly ironic that we only consider our elderly to be wise in fiction. Perhaps that’s because in fiction they’re usually proven to be right within a few hundred pages at most, whereas in real life it may be years or decades before the proof is evident–and by that time we’ve forgotten that they ever said anything at all. But the other half the equation in fiction usually proves just as true as it does in reality: the young whippersnapper to whom they dispense their wisdom almost never listens. To them, the aged are only wise when they tell them what they want to hear.

Posted in Random Musings | 7 Comments

The reactionary life

It would make for interesting performance art to put someone on a street corner and have them shout out the things posted on people’s Facebook feeds. Interesting in the way a Westboro Baptist Church protestor or a street prophet of questionable sanity is interesting. You’d want to duck your head, refuse to make eye contact, and hurry on.

This occurred to me the other night while wading through my Facebook feed. If a person’s Facebooking is a snapshot of their life, there are some of my friends I really have to feel bad for. They live to be offended, and seem to have few interests outside of freaking out over the latest injustice in their sphere of attention. They live angry, reactionary lives while providing little value other than to validate other angry, reactionary people. Granted, to look at my feed would probably suggest I have no life at all–and that’s probably true.

But, as I’ve observed many times before, I have to wonder if these people would really be like this in person. If they found themselves on a streetcorner with a handy soap box, would they choose to shout to the masses the same things they post to the masses online? I know I wouldn’t. I’m emboldened by the fact that my Facebook friends are supposedly just that–friends, and therefore might have some interest in what I have to say.

It makes me wonder what sort of image I project to my friends online. Hopefully I’m the wise old guy in the corner who only speaks when he has something interesting or useful to say. I doubt it, though. I’m probably the annoying guy who randomly blurts out something, but mostly just says, “If you want to know what I think, you’ll need to follow this link and read something long and tedious.” I rarely post much on Facebook, other than a link to my daily blog post. I probably comment more on other people’s posts than I post my own material.

But I digress. I understand a little negativity here and there, but there are people who spew up several dozen negative posts at a time, mostly angry reactions or reposting of other people’s angry reactions. I feel sorry and helpless–these people are clearly experiencing pain, are quite obviously not enjoying their life, and yet there is nothing I can do to help them. They would probably respond to my efforts to help with more angry reaction.

How do we help these people, I wonder. How do we reach out to those who seems as though they’re crying out for it, but in a medium very un-conducive to rendering true help? Social media is very good for broadcasting your hurt and pain, but very poor for responding to it in an effective, caring, personal way.

At the very least, I hope I don’t become like that myself. The world doesn’t need more negativity. The trick is learning how to become part of the solution.

Posted in Random Musings | Comments Off on The reactionary life

Disnefication

I know that it’s a running gag now of how Disney is going to ruin Star Wars. But this is pretty darn good…and almost makes me want to see it!

Posted in Random Musings | Comments Off on Disnefication

The happiest place on earth?

We have a big, energetic dog who likes to chase things. We also have yard that is limited in how much room there is to chase things. Fortunately we have a dog park not far from our house. We’ve begun taking Sam there now and then, and a few times I’ve been able to go along.

This weekend we went at a time we don’t usually go and found it a little crowded. But we were already there, and we needed to wear our dog out a little, so we stayed. Previously the other dogs have shown no interest in chasing a ball that wasn’t theirs, but this time was different. There were at least two different dogs who love chasing balls as much as our Sam, and they were both faster than him.

Sam didn’t care. He just loved the thrill of the chase. If someone else got it, that was fine, so long as they brought it back for another throw. I think we ultimately went home with a different ball than we’d brought, but that was not much of a concern. Dogs–well, at least most dogs–seem to know how to share.

We went again the next day and found it even more crowded. Big dogs, little dogs, young dogs, old dogs, purebreds, mutts. There was a trio of dogs that were the welcoming committee, blocking the gate to enter in their excitement to welcome newcomers. There were half a dozen dogs that circled around the park at random, checking out people and dogs and generally looking for entertainment. Pockets of dogs and people clustered here and there, some just watching everyone else, some just playing with their owners. Every so often a ball would go flying and a stampede of dogs would go hurtling after it.

The most fitting description was “Joyful chaos.” The only common denominator was that nearly every tail was wagging and every mouth was hanging open with tongues hanging out. Most every dog looked like they were having the absolute time of their life. Occasionally a play fight would break out, but otherwise dogs could bump one another, trip over one another, or jump on each other, but no one minded. They were all just focused on having fun, and could be incredibly patient in their pursuit of that fun.

You’re probably thinking I’m leading up to a moral about how people should learn to be more like dogs. If you’re thinking that, then I don’t need to. I mainly just wanted to try and describe a place I find particularly fun to hang out. Not everyone would, of course. Some people would find that a suitable definition of hell. But for me, a dog lover, there are few things more contagiously happy than a happy dog. Having a whole park full of them seems like, if not heaven, at least an awfully fun place to be.

Sam and his new friend Bubba. Bubba is pretty darn fast for a little guy.

Sam (right) and his new friend Bubba. They both love chasing balls. Bubba is pretty darn fast for a little guy.

Posted in Random Musings | 3 Comments